As readers of this blog know, federal spending costs you nothing. The government creates all the dollars it uses, ad hoc, every time it pays a bill. That is the absolute fact of federal financing that debt-liars try to deny
Since 1940, the federal government has created more than $22 trillion, net above taxes. That’s $22 trillion that even the tax scolds would have difficulty claiming as a taxpayers’ cost. Early in the 1780a, the government created the very first dollars from thin air.
It still creates dollars, and it will have no difficulty continuing to create endless dollars, also from thin air.
Even if all federal taxation ended, the government could keep spending forever. Federal taxes do not pay for anything.
Deficit spending does not cause inflation. The lack of federal deficit spending leads to recessions and depressions, while increased deficit spending cures recessions and depressions.
Inflation is caused by the shortages of key products and services. Today’s inflation is caused by the scarcity of food, oil, computer chips, labor, housing, and shipping. Inflation can be cured by federal deficit spending to procure and make available the scarce goods.
Despite the lack of cost to anyone, the Republican Party unanimously has opposed such benefits as:
-
- Universal prekindergarten: For all 3- and 4-year-olds. The claimed advantages of which are: social and emotional development, higher overall academic achievement, increased school success, less grade repetition, better high school graduation rates, higher achievement scores, and more advanced pre-literacy and math skills, and perhaps equally important, allows those parents who need to work, to provide a safe, educational environment for their young children.
- Subsidized child care for families earning less than $300,000. Child care cost is often higher than the cost of housing, college tuition, transportation, or food. It can be hard to find quality child care that is affordable. High-quality child care programs may cost more than other options. But when children are in a quality child care program they are able to develop, explore, and grow.
- Fighting climate change: Tax credits for the energy industry and consumers who switch to renewables, retrofitting buildings, and public transit to run on renewable energy, and giving tax credits for people to buy electric vehicles that could lower the cost of these vehicles by as much as $12,500.
- Strengthened Medicare: Beneficiaries’ out-of-pocket spending for Medicare’s drug benefit (Part D) would be capped at $2,000 per year and the cost for some insulin would be limited to $35 per month. Hearing coverage would be included. (Dental and vision coverage were eliminated in a failed attempt to get debt-lie votes).
- Extended tax credits and child payments: A one-year extension of the enhanced child tax credit (CTC). Lower-income workers in particular will be receiving these payments.
- Improved public housing and more affordable housing: Rental assistance, and many other listed benefits for low-income housing.
- Four weeks of paid family leave: Covers multiple reasons for leave-taking: To welcome a new child by birth, adoption, or foster care; to recover from a serious illness; or to care for a seriously ill family member. No one will have to choose between their paycheck and caring for a loved one or between their jobs and their own health.
If you’re among the very rich who don’t care what happens to those who aren’t rich, the above may not matter to you, though even you will not be immune to the ravages of climate change.
For the rest of us Americans and fellow human beings, the above constitute part of a long-overdue, financially wise, and moral effort. Sadly, ignorance hinders even the best-intentioned among us.
Consider Sen. Bernie Sanders:
“The American people overwhelmingly demand that the wealthy and large corporations pay their fair share of taxes.”
No, Bernie, corporations are not people. While proper taxing of wealthy people could narrow the Gap between the rich and the rest, taxing corporations has no economic value whatsoever. There is no “fair share” of a harmful program. The government doesn’t need or use tax dollars. Federal taxes simply take dollars from the private sector, and so, are recessionary.
“The American people overwhelmingly demand that we take on the greed of the pharmaceutical industry and lower the cost of prescription drugs.”
No, Bernie, it’s not “greed.” It’s just the normal profit motive. Price-fixing the drug industry simply will take research/development initiatives from the drug companies. There will be no benefit to the American public — if Medicare (aka the government) simply covers drug costs.
“The American people overwhelmingly demand that we expand Medicare to cover dental, eyeglasses and hearing aids.”
Yes, Bernie. There are zero good reasons why every part of the human body is covered, except teeth, eyes, and ears. What genius came up with those exclusions?
“The American people understand that we must act now to combat the existential threat of climate change and transform our energy system away from fossil fuels.”
Absolutely, Bernie. The human species faces several existential threats: Climate change, nuclear war, large meteors, supervolcanos, gamma-ray bursts, to name just a few. There’s not much we can do about what the universe will throw at us, but we have total control over climate change and nuclear war — or we would have total control if we could find a way to control the crazies.
Aside from avoiding the total obliteration of the human species, we have the power to improve our lot. We have the brains and money to support our health and wellbeing, by simply recognizing that our Monetarily Sovereign government has the infinite power to create money and to control its value.
We can educate all who want it, and provide shelter, food and medical aid to all who need it.
Despite being social “herd” animals, we have the brainpower to stop following dictators, dictator wannabes, rogues, charlatans, ne’er do wells, and false prophets, whose lies and selfishness have led us to disaster after disaster for their own benefit. (You already know who they are.}
As a people, we have lost so much to lies. The losses continue, accelerate, even. Today, American freedoms and democracy teeter on the edge. Fully two-thirds of the Republican party claims the presidential election was “stolen,” and that false claim provides the excuse for growing totalitarianism.
Today, dictatorships less often result from violent takeovers than by the creeping erosion of democracy. The rightward twisting of politics and laws, all justified by complaints from a psychopathic leader.
We see it happening in America, as it has happened around the world. It begins with:
- A psychopathic and charismatic leader, who:
- Acts not with reason but with bravado, vindictiveness, and feigned toughness.
- Claims the nation is in danger from the poor and that only he can save it from invented enemies.
- Helps the rich to become richer.
- Flaunts the trappings of wealth and power, gold, jewelry, palaces
- Boasts about cheating in his personal and his business lives.
- Claims perfection in all things and denies ever being wrong or losing.
- Takes credit for everything and the blame for nothing.
- Demands strict loyalty to him personally, rather than to the nation.
- Surrounds himself with immoral, even criminal, sycophants whom he can control.
- Corrupts the judiciary to legalize his sins
- Corrupts and undermines a free press.
- Corrupts the military while expressing disdain for its leaders.
- Corrupts the educational system when it does not support his bigotry.
- Claims to be religious, but denigrates compassion.
- Supports and disseminates demonstrably preposterous lies and conspiracy therories.
- Is a traitor, who supports overthrowing the U.S. government.
- Is a hate monger.
- Is a nepotist and would-be dictator.
- Claims, with no evidence, that America’s presidential election was illegal, and has coerced the Republican party into support his lies.
America is too big and powerful to lose its freedoms and democracy to an invader. We instead are losing our freedoms and democracy to internal rot.
The official mood no longer is “us.” It is “me only.” Selfishness is “smart.” The poor are “takers.” Foreigners are sinners. Cheating is clever. True patriots are “suckers.” Failure is someone else’s fault.
It is bad enough that we have lost, are losing, and will lose the benefits that President Biden originally proposed.
Worse, far worse, we are losing our heritage and our democracy.
We Are Losing America.
Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
Monetary Sovereignty
Twitter: @rodgermitchell
Search #monetarysovereignty
Facebook: Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
……………………………………………………………………..
THE SOLE PURPOSE OF GOVERNMENT IS TO IMPROVE AND PROTECT THE LIVES OF THE PEOPLE.
The most important problems in economics involve:
- Monetary Sovereignty describes money creation and destruction.
- Gap Psychology describes the common desire to distance oneself from those “below” in any socio-economic ranking, and to come nearer those “above.” The socio-economic distance is referred to as “The Gap.”
Wide Gaps negatively affect poverty, health and longevity, education, housing, law and crime, war, leadership, ownership, bigotry, supply and demand, taxation, GDP, international relations, scientific advancement, the environment, human motivation and well-being, and virtually every other issue in economics. Implementation of Monetary Sovereignty and The Ten Steps To Prosperity can grow the economy and narrow the Gaps:
Ten Steps To Prosperity:
- Eliminate FICA
- Federally funded Medicare — parts A, B & D, plus long-term care — for everyone
- Social Security for all
- Free education (including post-grad) for everyone
- Salary for attending school
- Eliminate federal taxes on business
- Increase the standard income tax deduction, annually.
- Tax the very rich (the “.1%”) more, with higher progressive tax rates on all forms of income.
- Federal ownership of all banks
- Increase federal spending on the myriad initiatives that benefit America’s 99.9%
The Ten Steps will grow the economy and narrow the income/wealth/power Gap between the rich and the rest.
MONETARY SOVEREIGNTY
A few reasons why we are LOSING AMERICA:
Admires dictators, Admitted “pussy grabber”, Adulterer, Anti-civil rights, Anti-black, Anti-brown, Anti-environment, Anti-Muslim, Anti-gay, Anti-truth, Anti-science, Arrogant, Bigot, Braggart, Breaks promises, Buck passer, Bully, Cheater, Childish name-caller, Climate-change denier, Collaborates with the enemy, Con artist, Conflicts of interest, Conspiracy theorist, Conspires with the enemy, Corrupt, Coward, Crazed, Criminal, Crooked, Crude, Cruel, Delusional, Demagogue, Denies obvious facts, Deranged, Dirty, Dishonest, Disgusting, Disingenuous, Disloyal, Disorganized, Draft dodger, Extortionist, Failing, Fake religionist, Greedy, Hatemonger, Hypocrite, Immature, Immoral, Incompetent, Indecisive, Inexperienced, Lazy, Leaker, Learning disability, Liar, Loathsome, Maligner, Mean-spirited, Misogynist, Narcissistic, Nativist, Nepotist, Obese, Obstructs justice, Petty, Phony, Psychopath, Racist, Scammer, Self-absorbed, Self-centered, Self-congratulatory, Serial insulter, Sleazy, Stupid, Takes from the poor; gives to the rich, Traitor, Uncharitable, Unfaithful, Unqualified, Unreliable, Unstable, Weakling, Whoremonger, Whores’ john
LikeLike
What the democracy watchers worry about: https://www.axios.com/what-democracy-watchers-worry-about-10ee7c53-cee2-44bd-9c55-5364af9750ed.html
For those who believe that somehow Trump was exonerated regarding his involvement with Russia: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/it-wasn-t-a-hoax/ar-AAR7Efc?ocid=msedgntp
LikeLike
/Rodger. Wonderful post that sums up a lot. Will forward to others. Happy Thanksgiving.
LikeLike
Thanks, Charles.
LikeLike
Your comment about NOT taxing corporations is incomplete and perhaps wrong. They use their profits to shape govt policy and public opinion. If the tax system was properly structured and they were taxed properly without the loopholes and deductions, that would go a long ways toward ameliorating other problems that you have identified. It is NOT happening because the politicians and media are owned by the corporations.
Questions that come to mind include are corporate taxes and hence increases inflationary since they add to the price of goods and services? Taxes could force different decisions on management about where they spend company resources which then impacts prices as well as shareholder value. It is highly complex.
LikeLike
I do not think taxing corporations — i.e taking dollars from the private sector and giving them to the government, where they will be destroyed — will address the problems you mention.
Large corporations are nothing more than money conduits for the rich. These conduits do many things, one extremely tiny part of which is to bribe politicians. You could tax Apple, Microsoft, Tesla et al billions of dollars, and they still would have plenty of dollars to bribe politicians.
These corporations could spend millions on bribes, and those millions would be pocket change to the corporations. You simply cannot tax them enough to make a political difference without also crippling the businesses. It would be like trying to dry the ocean with a paper towel.
The real problem is the right-wing SCOTUS misinterpretation of the First Amendment, which allows unlimited political bribery.
LikeLike
Rodger, you have summed up the current corrosion of our democratic foundation. Yes, i am thankful for many things today, but there is a sadness of heart too as all you outlined creeps into our lives. Thank you for your observations and voice of concern.
LikeLike
Excellent post Rodger. Every member of the idiocracy that admires Trump or any of his imitators should ponder it.
Taxes are not necessary to fund the government, but they are necessary as both a cudgel and an incentive because without such means there would undoubtedly be very little compliance with what the rational component of government wanted to accomplish. Having said this tax rates need not be as high as they are now…unless you are an anti-social operator and arbitrarily inflate and then they should be extremely punitary. I favor cutting taxes at least in half, but if you inflate despite the cost savings of that 50% tax reduction then every cent of revenue gained from that inflation should be taxed at a rate of 100%…and that revenue distributed equally to your competitors.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I fundamentally disagree that taxing corporations is a bad thing. Taxes can and should be used to force better behavior by taxing those things like pollution and the promotion of social unrest through once gouging and false advertising. sure that tax money won’t fund anything but it might force them to make better decisions environmentally and socially and stop feeding the minster so to speak.
LikeLike
Yes, tax the bad thing, not overall income. Corporate income is not a bad thing.
LikeLike
Why Don’t We See Headlines Touting the Pentagon’s Hefty Price Tag?
Posted on November 25, 2021 by Yves Smith
LikeLike
Does RMM agree with Mosler here that the Headline Left are Still Dead Wrong on National Debt, Deficits & Taxes? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jiGjaHOm9Q4
LikeLike
YES!
LikeLike
What was the point of tightwad Bernie briefly hiring that Kelton if he was never ever going to listen to her about anything? “Bernie says he has been a fiscal conservative all his life and he’s not going to change now” (wonder if any of his supporters know that about him).
Psychiatry must have a name for an affliction where people derive pleasure from intentionally setting themselves up to fail over and over again. Whatever that is pretty much all of the Headline Left must be infected with it.
LikeLike
“I have been a ______________________ all my life and I’m not going to change now,” is a statement that ranks high on the stupidity scale.
LikeLike
“And so to show they too are indeed fiscally responsible grownups who wouldn’t think of instigating such a financial crisis, the headline progressives more than agree that the federal deficit is indeed a very dangerous long term menace that demands appropriate attention.” https://www.huffpost.com/entry/modern-monetary-theory-th_b_872449 A decade since and little has changed with the vast masses still unaware that for example the only thing we owe to China is a monthly bank statement.
LikeLike
And even Warren Mosler, whom I respect greatly, buys into this myth: ” . . . hyperinflation comes only from sustained overspending far beyond full employment and our capacity to produce.”
It’s not the “overspending” that causes inflation (or hyperinflation), but the shortages. Inflations never are caused by federal spending, though federal spending can be caused by inflation. You can have inflation without the federal government spending a dime if, for instance, there would be a massive national crop failure or an oil embargo.
There is no historical relationship between federal deficit spending and inflation. See: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/fredgraph.png?g=Juh6
LikeLike