Donald Trump complains about being witch-hunted, but not many people really understand that a witch-hunt is not just something Trump doesn’t like being done to him (he claims).
Ron DeSantis has instituted his own version of witch-hunting with his battle against “grooming,” the hair-brained, fact-devoid belief that gay people try to influence otherwise straight children to become gay.
The similarities between 14th through 20th-century actual witch-hunting and today’s GOP “woke-hunting” are frightening.
Edet Eyo, a 69-year-old woman from Cross River State in Nigeria, and four others were murdered in October 2022, allegedly by a group of young men who charged that her witchcraft had caused a recent motorcycle crash.
Her family says that suspicions had been dogging her for years, arising from jealousy of her prosperity. It is also the tale of Martha Carrier, who was hanged in Salem, Mass., in 1692.
Punishment for witches
Of the accusations against her, one of the most salient was by a neighbor with whom her family had a property dispute.
Carrier became one of 35 people executed for witchcraft in the British colonies of New England—“crimes” of which some of them still have not been exonerated.
Every year more than 1,000 people around the world, including men and children, are tortured, expelled from their homes or killed after being charged with witchcraft—using magic, usually to cause harm.
Far from declining with modernization, as some 20th-century scholars predicted, witch hunts are holding steady in some places and may be happening more often in others.
Multiple roots entwine to produce a witch hunt. A belief in sorcery, a patriarchal society, sudden and a paucity of health care, inaccessible justice systems that give impunity to attackers, a triggering disaster—all of these contribute.
But as Silvia Federici has argued in her 2004 book Caliban and the Witch and subsequent publications, what sustained periods of witch-hunting have in common, across time, space and culture, is a backdrop of social and economic dislocation.
Today’s triggering disaster was the COVID pandemic exacerbated by the Trump (“It will just go away) adminstration’s incompetence and lying, leading to more than a million American deaths.
Although popular imagination regards the trials as outbreaks of mass delusion or superstition, the fact that they peaked between the 1580s and the 1630s, a time of massive upheaval as a capitalist economy emerged, suggests a different story.
Church leaders had initiated witch huntsin the late 15th century, in part as a way of policing social mores.
Now the state, which was closely allied with religious, political and economic elites, took the lead.
In the 16th century rulers across Europe introduced new laws to make sorcery punishable by death—and the trials moved from ecclesiastical to secular courts, such as in duchies and towns.
Historian Christina Larner writes that in Scotland, authorities systematically incited panic against witches, traveling from village to village to instruct people on how to recognize them and sometimes even bringing along lists of women to denounce.
In sum, witch-hunting was a systematic campaign of terror that eliminated the resistance to dispossession that had simmered for decades after the peasant protests were crushed.
The accusations and persecution died down only in the latter half of the 18th century. Historical records indicate that by that time, roughly 50,000 people had been executed for sorcery.
That was then. Now, review what a modern witch-hunt looks like. Here are excerpts from a July 1, 2022 article in Vanity Fair Magazine:
Ron DeSantis has a not-insignificant chance of becoming president in 2024.
Like Trump, the Florida governor takes immense pride in being a bully; he bullied the Special Olympics, he bullied Disney, he bullies anyone who disagrees with him.
What might the country look like should DeSantis ascend to the White House? It’ll be the kind of place where teachers are warned not to display rainbow flags for fear of being prosecuted.
On Friday, Desantis’s Parental Rights in Education Act, a.k.a. the “Don’t Say Gay” law, went into effect in Florida, and it’s hard to overstate how terrifying this whole thing is.
In addition to banning any talk of gender identity and sexual orientation in kindergarten through third grade, it also prohibits such discussions all the way through high school, saying that such topics cannot be discussed in any grade in a manner that is not “age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate.”
(Naturally, the law does not specify what is considered “appropriate”; that definition may not come from the state’s Department of Education until next summer.)
Critics believe the law was written in an intentionally broad manner to scare school districts, which parents can sue if they believe the measure has been violated.
“When we talk about the culture of fear that this bill has created and the chilling effect, we’re talking about the fact that educators and school districts are scared to approach anything related to LGBTQ people or issues out of fear of lawsuits and professional ruin,” said Florida representative Carlos Guillermo Smith.
Ironically, the law is based on not wanting students to “feel uncomfortable.” Instead, it makes teachers and gay students terrified, and the rest of the students, vigilantes.
The common elements between the earlier witch-hunts and today’s GOP witch hunts are:
Politically powerful bigots who amass power by appealing to the ignorance, hatred and fears of the common populace.
The article continues:
For instance, the Orange County Classroom Teachers Association accused school officials this week of telling teachers not to wear clothing with rainbows on them and to get rid of “safe space” stickers and photos of their same-sex spouses.
Last month, according to Palm Beach County high school special education teacher Michael Woods, the Palm Beach County School District “sent out a questionnaire asking its teachers to review all course material and flag any books with references to sexual orientation, gender identity or race.”
Hitler would be proud.
The district removed the books I Am Jazz and Call Me Max, for seemingly referencing gender identity.
Medieval mask of shame
And, the Leon County School Board approved a “LGBTQ Inclusive Guide,” which includes a clause that says parents must be informed if a student who is “open about their gender identity” is in their child’s gym class or with them on an overnight school trip.
Apparently, that gay child represents some sort of threat to other children. (In reality, the other children represent a threat to a gay child.)
“Upon notification or determination of a student who is open about their gender identity, parents of the affected students will be notified of reasonable accommodation options available,” the guidelines state.
“Reasonable accommodations” for the gay child? For the straight children? What does that mean”
“Parents or students who have concerns about rooming assignments for their student’s upcoming overnight event based on religious or privacy concerns may request an accommodation.”
Because, as “everyone” knows, gay children have a reputation for attacking straight children. I never heard of that happening — the straights usually attack the gays — but one can’t be too careful because rooming with a gay child might turn a straight child gay. Right?
The “badge of shame” during the Holocaust
At any rate, we have done our job by stigmatizing the gay children, thus assuring they will be bullied in school, which is exactly what any God-fearing parent should want. Right?
What next? Brand gay students with a “G” on their foreheads? Make them wear yellow armbands as the Jews had to, during the German Nazi period? Make them play in a separate schoolyard, so they don’t contaminate the “normal” kids?
From Wikipedia: In England, under the Poor Act 1697, paupers in receipt of parish relief were required to wear a badge of blue or red clothon the shoulder of the right sleeve in an open and visible manner, in order to discourage people from collecting relief unless they were desperate, as while many would be willing to collect relief, few would be willing to do so if required to wear the “shameful” mark of the poor in public
Brandon Wolf,press secretary for Equality Florida, said, “We’ve always understood what we’re up against in the state of Florida. We know these lawmakers, we know the rightward shift that has happened under Governor Ron DeSantis.”
He fears the measure will only increase anti-LGBTQ+ violence, which increased from 2020 to 2021 and is on track to be worse in 2022, according to the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project.
But we DeSantis supporters don’t care about anti-LGBTQ+ violence, do we. Those gay kids have it coming for violating my religious beliefs. Right?
The scarlet letter
“It feels very ominous that in a state that saw the deadliest attack on LGBTQ people in this nation’s history…that we would be having conversations about erasing our history, our lives, our lived experiences from classrooms,” Wolf said.
Meanwhile, in Texas… A group of “educators” proposed that slavery should be called “involuntary relocation.”
Yes, really!
Opposition to the suggested change, which would sort of be like calling Hitler’s systemic murder of 6 million Jews “population downsizing,”apparently came up during a June 15 meeting, at which a Democrat who represents Dallas and Fort Worth noted that the new wording would not be a “fair representation” of the slave trade.
How about calling the Romans’ feeding of Christians to lions, “animal welfare nourishment”?
And then there was this bit of witch-hunt bigotry, courtesy of religion (Why isbigotry so often based on supposed religious belief?)
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued a final rule earlier this week expanding health care workers’ ability to refuse services on religious grounds.
How about, “My religion doesn’t recognize Jews, so no service for you.”
Or, “My religion tells me that blacks are evil, so you can’t rent in my building”?
Or, “My religion says gay people are breaking God’s laws, so off to jail with you?”
Or, “My religion says abortion is murder, so despite what your religion says, all abortions will be prosecuted as capital crimes, and everyone involved — doctors, lawyers, those facilitating travel for abortions, everyone — will be punished by death?”
That ought to do it.
A number of LGBTQ advocates and health care experts have warned the measure could have a negative impact on the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer community.
That’s the whole point. Why do you think we made you queers scapegoats? We’re trying to get the bigot vote in America.
The rule, Protecting Statutory Conscience Rights in Health Care, revises existing HHS regulations to ensure “vigorous enforcement of Federal conscience and anti-discrimination laws” and strengthens health care workers rights so they are “free from coercion or discrimination” on account of their “religious beliefs or moral convictions.”
The measure, first proposed over a year ago, “fulfills President Trump’s promise to promote and protect the fundamental and unalienable rights of conscience and religious liberty,” according to a statement issued by the HHS.
What we mean is the “fundamental and unalianable rights of me,” not the rights of anyone who thinks differently, looks different or acts differently from me.
See it’s like this: Any person’s claimed religious beliefs are more important than the actual health and lives of gay people.
Yes, in the latest round of the Florida governor versus the state’s largest employer, DeSantis threatenedon Monday to punish the company through any array of absurd measures, including building a prison complex next to the theme park.
(DeSantis’s threats were obvious retribution for the way Disney outmaneuvered him by passing covenants that rendered his handpicked governing board basically powerless.)
At a press conference held near Disney World, DeSantis sneered and spoke of the company: “They are not superior to the laws that are enacted by the people of the state of Florida. That’s not going to work, that’s not going to fly.”
Actually, the laws were not enacted by the people. They were enacted by DeSantis and his flunkees, who care only about their power, and nothing about innocent gay people.
Then, after announcing that the Republican-controlled legislature would try to change state law in order to subject the theme park to new inspections, he suggested that the land next to Disney World might be turned into a rival park or perhaps a state prison.
Oh, and the board he personally installed may look into raising Disney’s taxes too.
But that’s not the “weaponizing of the government against political opponents” that the GOP loves to whine about.
As a reminder, all of this is happening because Disney dared to criticizethe wildly bigoted, DeSantis-backed “Don’t Say Gay”legislation last year in Florida, where you’re apparently not allowed to disagree with the authoritarian governor.
Even former New Jersey governor and potential 2024 Republican candidate for president Chris Christie recognized the lunacy of DeSantis’s antics, asking, “Where are we headed here now, that if you express disagreement in this country, the government is allowed to punish you?”
On Monday, Disney seemingly responded to DeSantis’s threats by publicizing “Disneyland After Dark: Pride Nite,” a two-night event that will be held in June to celebrate the LGBTQ+ community and its allies.
Oh, that does it. No doubt the “Disneyland After Dark: Pride Nite” will “groom” dozens if not thousands of straight kids to convert to a lifestyle that guarantees they forever will be scapegoat for the religious. Who could resist such an option?
We’re assuming that didn’t go over so great in the governor’s mansion, and that DeSantis is currently asking his lawyers to look into whether he can have Mickey executed.
DeSantis probably doesn’t harbor a true hatred of gays, blacks, Mexicans, immigrants, Muslims et al. He is just trying to live off the precudices of Florida voters.
Presumably, his massive victory in the most recent elections indicated he judged his constituency correctly.
Fortunately, the rest of America is not Florida, and DeSantis’s national polling number are dropping.
But unfortuately, that leaves the bigoted GOP with Donald Trump, the guy who whines about witch-hunting while endorsing it.
Get the ducking stools and yellow arm bands, ready.
Do you generally vote Republican, Democrat, or independent? The two main parties have changed during the past few decades. Republicans have moved to the right. Democrats have split.
Have you moved with them?
Here are some beliefs often expressed in the news. How many beliefs do you agree with? Be honest with yourself.
TRUE or FALSE
Donald Trump did much to make America great, again._____
Donald Trump did not attempt a coup._____
Trump was cheated out of the Presidency by fraudulent voting._____
It’s OK that Trump employed his family in the White House._____
Trump has not committed serious criminal acts._____
It doesn’t matter whether or not Trump cheated on three wives._____
It doesn’t matter whether or not Trump paid federal taxes._____
FOX News provides reliable news.____
Tucker Carlson provides reliable news._____
The COVID vaccination is dangerous or useless._____
COVID masks don’t work._____
Scientific studies about climate change and COVID often lie._____
God actually exists._____
Christianity is the only true religion._____
Atheists are a grave danger to America. _____
Abortion is murder._____
Gun control laws take away my 2nd Amendment rights._____
Easy access to guns makes Americans safer._____
School teachers should be armed_____
The 2nd Amendment does not say gun owners should be in a well-regulated Militia,_____
I favor open-carry of guns._____
There should be no restrictions on the size of gun magazines._____
Medicare for All is a bad idea._____
There should be no separation between church and state._____
Women generally are not as capable as men._____
Blacks tend to be lazy, criminal, and/or receive too many free benefits._____
Blacks receive unfair advantages._____
Mexicans and other Latins tend to be lazy, criminal, and/or receive too many free benefits._____
Undocumented immigrants are a danger to America._____
Orientals are taking over America._____
Jews are trying to take over the world._____
Native Americans are not civilized._____
The poor tend to be takers, not producers._____
Global warming is not man-made._____
White supremacists are correct in much of what they say._____
QAnon is right about a lot of things.
We are being replaced by non-white, non-Christians_____
The Supreme Court was wrong not to have declared Obamacare unconstitutional._____
Food stamps and most other poverty aids are a bad idea._____
Building affordable housing for the poor in my area is a bad idea_____
We need increased military spending_____
There should be no immigration path to citizenship_____
Gay marriage is morally wrong._____
Gays are grooming young children to be gay._____
Muslims are a danger to America._____
There are some crimes for which I favor the death penalty._____
Being born in America should not guarantee citizenship._____
DACA children (“Dreamers”) should be sent home._____
Most illegal drugs come into America via undocumented immigrants._____
Children should not be allowed to have gender-affirming treatment._____
A history of slavery and bigotry in America should not be taught.____
Parents know better than teachers what their children should be taught._____
The burning of books is appropriate in some cases._____
If you answered “False” to almost all of the above you probably are a Democrat or an independent depending on the number of False’s.
If you answered “True” to about half, you probably are a Republican or a RINO. You could slide either way.
If you answered “True” to more than half of the above, you are a Trump Republican.
Nice to discover who you really are, isn’t it? Proud of it?
Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
Monetary SovereigntyTwitter: @rodgermitchellSearch #monetarysovereigntyFacebook: Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
……………………………………………………………………..
THE SOLE PURPOSE OF GOVERNMENT IS TO IMPROVE AND PROTECT THE LIVES OF THE PEOPLE.
Gap Psychology describes the common desire to distance oneself from those “below” in any socio-economic ranking, and to come nearer those “above.” The socio-economic distance is referred to as “The Gap.”
Wide Gaps negatively affect poverty, health and longevity, education, housing, law and crime, war, leadership, ownership, bigotry, supply and demand, taxation, GDP, international relations, scientific advancement, the environment, human motivation and well-being, and virtually every other issue in economics.Implementation of Monetary Sovereignty and The Ten Steps To Prosperity can grow the economy and narrow the Gaps: Ten Steps To Prosperity:
The debt hawks are to economics as the creationists are to biology. Those, who do not understand monetary sovereignty, do not understand economics. Cutting the federal deficit is the most ignorant and damaging step the federal government could take. It ranks ahead of the Hawley-Smoot Tariff.
================================================================================================================================================================
Who are these people who want to arrest and deport all undocumented non-citizens, as well as repeal the law that gives citizenship to everyone born here?
Who are these people who want to prevent a Muslim mosque two blocks distant from ground zero?
Who are these people who wish to repeal health care insurance for millions of people who otherwise could not afford to pay?
Who are these people who want to prevent gays from having the same marriage benefits as straights? Who are these people who want to continue the humiliating ‘Don’t ask; don’t tell” military policy? Who are these people who ordered the Pentagon to send a questionnaire asking soldiers their opinions about serving with gays and lesbians.
Asking soldiers their opinions??? Is this the way the army now is run? By survey? What next, a questionnaire asking, “How do you feel about being sent to Afghanistan and getting blown up by a roadside bomb?” Or perhaps, “How do you feel about taking orders you don’t like?” Will military policy be dictated by the answers?
One of the questions in the survey is, “If Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell is repealed and you are assigned to bathroom facilities with an open bay shower that someone you believe to be a gay or lesbian Service member also used, which are you most likely to do?” What if instead of “gay and lesbian,” we substitute the word “black,” would that be appropriate? Or how about, “Muslim”? Good idea?
Who are these people who wrap themselves in the American flag, but have forgotten the words on the Statue of Liberty? Who are these people who wave their piety in your face, but deny the basic tenets of their religion and indeed, all religions?
The bigotry in America has ramped up. When economic times are bad, the devils and the saints show their true colors. You can tell the merit of people by the way they act in a life boat. Now that we share life boat America, listen to what is being said and look at what is being done, and ask yourself: “Who are these people?
No nation can tax itself into prosperity. Those who say the stimulus “didn’t work” remind me of the guy whose house is on fire. A neighbor runs with a garden hose and starts spraying, but the fire continues. The neighbor wants to call the fire department, which would bring the big hoses, but the guy says, “Don’t call. As you can see, water doesn’t put out fires.”